39 Photos

$166,000

208 Benton Street

Athens, New Athens, Illinois, 62264

MLS® 26058604 · Listed by Tammy Mitchell Hines & Co.

3 bedrooms2 bathrooms2272.00 sqftResidential0 days on marketBuilt 1914Lot 8712.00$3,018 taxes (2025)1 garageForced Air · Central AirUnfinished basement
Take the virtual tour

About this property

This sweet SEARS CATALOG Craftsman home radiates charm, character, and curb appeal from the moment you arrive. Thoughtfully preserved historic details—original woodwork, wide trim, solid doors, large windows, built-in bookcases, window-seat storage, and a gorgeous period breakfront—create an unmistakably warm, storybook feel. Even the original mail slot in the front door remains, a delightful nod to the home’s heritage. Inside, nearly 2,300 sq. ft. of finished living space offers comfort, flexibility, and room to grow with 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. The open living/dining layout is anchored by a striking Craftsman architectural divider featuring built-ins and lines that guide your eye toward the spacious dining room. Here, wood beams, a window bench, and the original breakfront make the space perfect for everyday meals or hosting friends. The living room’s converted electric fireplace adds cozy ambiance, and the practical flooring throughout the main level makes the home both beautiful and easy to maintain. The updated kitchen is a standout—shaker-style cabinetry, solid-surface counters, stainless appliances, a walk-in pantry, and main-floor laundry create a highly functional workspace. Every detail feels intentional, blending modern convenience with the home’s timeless character. Two generous main-floor bedrooms offer comfortable living arrangements—one with brand-new carpet (2026) and the other with seamless flooring that flows from the main living areas. The remodeled full bath features a tub/shower combo, comfort-height vanity, and elevated commode. Upstairs, a spacious private suite spans the entire level, complete with a full bath, tub/shower combo, a huge walk-in closet, and additional storage nooks—ideal for a quiet retreat, guest suite, or flex space. Outside, the fully fenced backyard provides room to play, garden, or relax. Alley access offers private off-street parking in addition to the 1-car detached garage (with 60-amp service). A large concrete patio sits just off the back of the home—perfect for summer evenings, grilling, or gathering with friends. The dry, unfinished basement adds abundant storage options. Major updates for peace of mind: Roof, HVAC, water heater, wiring, windows, gutters, insulation, appliances, bathroom remodels (all 2019) • Fence 2020 • Added counters/cabinets 2022 • New carpet 2026.

Ask Maryam about this home

Your details go directly to Maryam and are never shared.

Estimated value

$172,559

Estimated range: $165,389 $179,729 · 4% confidence

Estimated value by month

Estimated value trend from Oct 2025 ($150,079) to Sep 2026 ($172,559)Oct 2025Sep 2026

This is an automated estimate based on MLS® market data — not an appraisal or a substitute for professional advice.

Curious what your own home is worth? Get a free estimate →

Comparable recent sales

Sold records the MLS® data provider selected as comparable to this home — nearby recent sales at a similar price, bed count, and property type. Locations are shown at the neighborhood level only.

SoldAug 27, 2026

$180,000

Listed at $174,900

N/A, Ste Genevieve, Missouri

3 bd · 2 ba · 2312.00 sqft · Residential

SoldJun 22, 2026

$160,000

Listed at $170,000

Caroline Popes, St Louis, Missouri

3 bd · 2 ba · 2352.00 sqft · Residential

SoldJul 23, 2026

$162,500

Listed at $174,900

N/A, Canton, Missouri

3 bd · 2 ba · 2182.00 sqft · Residential

MLS® data for this listing last updated Sep 16, 2026.

Market snapshot

The Athens, New Athens market

Closed sales in Athens, New Athens over the last 12 months.

$0

Median sold price

0

Avg. days on market