$429,000
42 Hickory Street
S14 T3S R3W LOT #42 2ND SUB, Nashville, Illinois, 62263
MLS® 26037549 · Listed by Keller Williams Pinnacle
About this property
Situated on approximately two acres in a private lake community offering fishing and boating, this unique property offers over 7,000 square feet of finished space between the main home and guest home. The main residence features approximately 2,388 square feet with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a beautiful kitchen, dining area, sitting room, living room with fireplace, and laundry options on both the main floor and basement. A 470-square-foot deck overlooks the private backyard, firepit area, and wooded backdrop. The approximately 4,700-square-foot guest home offers a full kitchen, open living and dining area, bedroom, two full bathrooms, mirrored exercise room, large bar, theater seating and movie area, plus multiple flex rooms ideal for offices, crafts, storage, playrooms, or additional sleeping space. Additional features include geothermal heating in the main home, propane heat in the guest home/storage building, and an attached one-car garage at the guest house. The property is situated on two parcels and offers exceptional space, privacy, and versatility in a lake community setting.
Comparable recent sales
Sold records the MLS® data provider selected as comparable to this home — nearby recent sales at a similar price, bed count, and property type. Locations are shown at the neighborhood level only.
$391,000
Listed at $400,000
At Lincoln Farm 2nd Add, O'Fallon, Illinois
3 bd · 2 ba · 2256.00 sqft · Residential
$394,000
Listed at $389,900
Country Village Estates, Troy, Illinois
3 bd · 3 ba · 2422.00 sqft · Residential
$400,600
Listed at $415,000
Grandbrook Estates, Collinsville, Illinois
3 bd · 3 ba · 2428.00 sqft · Residential
$410,000
Listed at $380,000
Hunters Crossing, Edwardsville, Illinois
3 bd · 3 ba · 2288.00 sqft · Residential
$447,700
Listed at $399,995
Finestowne Ridge 1 Amd, St Louis, Missouri
3 bd · 3 ba · 2343.00 sqft · Residential
$455,000
Listed at $459,000
Crystal Lake 1, St Louis, Missouri
3 bd · 3 ba · 2300.00 sqft · Residential
MLS® data for this listing last updated Aug 27, 2026.