30 Photos

$300,000

5241 Sutherland Avenue

Christys Add, St Louis, Missouri, 63109

MLS® 26023345 · Listed by Compass Realty Group

0 bedrooms2300.00 sqftResidential Income5 days on marketBuilt 1923Lot 4251.46$3,541 taxes (2025)Forced Air,Natural Gas · Central Air,ElectricUnfinished,Walk-Up Access basement

About this property

This charming brick two-family property offers classic South City character, spacious interiors, and an exciting opportunity for both investors and owner-occupants. Each unit features 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath, with generous living spaces, separate dining areas, beautiful hardwood flooring, crown molding, built-in details, and abundant natural light throughout. The interior was updated approximately 20 years ago and offers a bright, neutral foundation ready for its next owner’s personal touch. Behind the scenes, the property features PVC plumbing, an updated 150-amp electrical panel, and newer water heaters. The HVAC system is approximately 20 years old. The kitchen presents a unique opportunity to customize the space to suit your style. Seller is open to negotiating the installation of kitchen finishes as part of the sale, with the purchase price adjusted accordingly based on mutually agreed-upon finishes and scope of work. Renderings are available to showcase the potential of the finished space. Additional features include central air, forced-air natural gas heating, an unfinished walk-up basement with laundry, and a two-car carport. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio, live in one unit while generating income from the other, or create a flexible multi-generational living arrangement, 5241 Sutherland offers character, versatility, and plenty of potential in a classic St. Louis setting. *Seller is open to negotiating the installation of kitchen finishes as part of the sale. Should the buyer select to have the kitchen completed, the purchase price will be adjusted accordingly based on the mutually agreed-upon finishes and scope of work. Seller is willing to negotiate an agreed-upon price for the completed kitchen.

Ask Maryam about this home

Your details go directly to Maryam and are never shared.

Estimated value

$308,124

Estimated range: $293,370 – $322,879 · 5% confidence

Estimated value by month

Estimated value trend from Oct 2025 ($280,351) to Sep 2026 ($308,124)Oct 2025Sep 2026

This is an automated estimate based on MLS® market data — not an appraisal or a substitute for professional advice.

Curious what your own home is worth? Get a free estimate →

Comparable recent sales

Sold records the MLS® data provider selected as comparable to this home — nearby recent sales at a similar price, bed count, and property type. Locations are shown at the neighborhood level only.

SoldJul 21, 2026

$275,000

Listed at $279,000

Northampton Add, St Louis, Missouri

0 bd · 2328.00 sqft · Residential Income

SoldJun 13, 2026

$330,000

Listed at $325,000

Northampton, St Louis, Missouri

0 bd · 2250.00 sqft · Residential Income

SoldJun 29, 2026

$330,000

Listed at $349,900

Oak Hill Add, St Louis, Missouri

0 bd · 2208.00 sqft · Residential Income

Similar properties

MLS® data for this listing last updated Sep 8, 2026.

Market snapshot

The Christys Add, St Louis market

Closed sales in Christys Add, St Louis over the last 12 months.

$267,500

Median sold price

31

Avg. days on market

8

Homes sold

Median sold price by month

Median sold price trend from Oct 2025 ($285,000) to Jul 2026 ($250,000)Oct 2025Jul 2026